Thread-topic: [EXLIBRIS] Old-Fashioned Definition of "Wrong" (was Mr. Smiley's lawyer)
" Check with the casino industry. They do an excellent
job of recording everything that goes on where
valueables (money & chips) are handled.
C.J. Scheiner "
Yes, and their patrons pay to play. Perhaps libraries should charge
their patrons?
Maybe instead of chiding libraries for failing to make patrons view
materials through bullet-proof glass, we should ask why book and art
dealers so frequently traffic in stolen goods; why they are sometimes
little better than high-end pawn-brokers, preferring to make a good buy
rather than ask questions; why some are thieves themselves--at least a
couple have been mentioned on this list in the past few months. Right?
I think we would be better off acknowledging that because libraries
exist for the public good and their materials are there to be used, bad
actors will find ways to steal, mutilate or destroy those materials.
Libraries can, and do, try to prevent theft and damage; but certainly,
some should do more. But in most libraries, security runs up against
access and money. People give money for books; people give money for
buildings; nobody gives money to improve security. And where access and
security clash, access has to win, otherwise libraries aren't serving
their primary function. So again, books will be stolen. And chances
are, sooner or later, they will fall into dealers' hands. Dealers can,
and do, try to identify stolen materials and make sure they get back
where they belong; but certainly, some should do more.
Smiley will be getting a good deal if he gets the maximum sentence.
Whatever it is will be better than the minimum for 97 counts. He
deserves no lenience; he's already gotten plenty.
Patrick
Patrick Cates
Technical Services Librarian
St. Mark's Library
General Theological Seminary
175 Ninth Avenue
New York, NY 10011
212-243-5150 x354
This e-mail was sent from the GTS e-mail service. If you are not the intended recipient of this email, please notify the sender immediately or call us at 212.243.5150 x376.